Vague de réprimandes dans le milieu spatial...à venir!

Report of the Deputy Prime Minister SB Ivanov on measures of discipline for the failure of the implementation of the state defense order
:: 05/17/2011

Deputy Prime Minister Sergei Ivanov reported to President on the execution of his assignments of responsibility of officials for the failure to implement the state defense order. Instruction is given at the meeting on the development of military-industrial complex of Russia, held on May 10, 2011.

Questions of increasing the accountability of officials for the implementation of the state defense order, including the implementation of the relevant supply, have repeatedly discussed in the Russian Federation Government and the Military-Industrial Commission under the Government of the Russian Federation, in connection with what was adopted by a number of personnel decisions.

In accordance with the instructions of the President of Russia taken disciplinary action to the decision makers of organizations that have failed to supply arms and military equipment in 2010.

The adoption of specific measures:

for reducing the production management activities of subordinate enterprises, the lack of the required coordination of work assignments at the state defense order for 2010 General Designer and General Director of "Information Satellite Systems" NA Testoedovu, General Director of JSC VPK NPO Machine Building A. G. Leonov reprimanded. For the low level of leadership organizations aerospace industry to build the spacecraft for military purposes is proposed reprimand the deputy head of Russian Federal Space Agency and AE Shilov.

Removed from his post of general director of OAO Izhmash VP Grodetsky and Federal State Unitary Enterprise "Research Institute of Electromechanics" AE Hohlovich.

In addition, measures of administrative and disciplinary measures in respect of 8 heads of other organizations of the defense industry be allowed to fail assignments of the state defense order.

At the June 2011 scheduled meeting of the Board of Directors of Sevmash on compliance of the CEO of the company NY Kalistratova. There are also plans to review the boards of directors of subsidiaries of OAO United Aircraft Corporation "questions about the personal responsibility of their leaders for failing aircraft delivery schedules.

Due to shortages in military equipment in the Russian Defense Ministry dismissed from military service, a number of officials from the governing bodies of ordering military administration, including Deputy Chief of the Armed Forces, Major-General I. Vaganov, head of development and management orders aviation equipment and weapons, Colonel I. Krylov, deputy commander of the Navy's armament Vice Admiral NK Borisov.

Accepted staffing solutions for organizations of defense industry executives and officials of the Ministry of Defense of Russia, allowed to fail tasks of state defense order in 2010, is sufficient both to improve performance discipline and personal responsibility, and prevent violations of the terms of delivery of products to the customer.

According to materials of the site of the President of the Russian Federation (http://www.kremlin.ru/news/11257)

Indeed, Deputy Prime Minister Sergei B. Ivanov, speaking before the heads of agencies and telecommunications companies expressed serious concern that is not built in time series of satellite state defense order. The reasons are clear. Many of them have an objective character. In particular, more than expected, it took time for the purchase of imported components. Identified failures of some components in the manufacture and testing of onboard equipment. Part of it had to be sent to the factory. Agree, this is the right decision - to ensure quality.

Another group of reasons related to the lack of a sufficient number of second jobs in a number of factory-board equipment included a satellite cooperation. The explanation for this is. In previous years, when the orders of satellites are not large enough, say, a ruler of jobs in the supply chain enterprise. When the orders increased, the production cycle began running jobs, manufacturing sites and personnel.

In this case, the enterprise, and including us, are facing a dilemma: either to invest a lot of money, hundreds of millions of rubles in the creation of a second job, or still try to stay within one line of production equipment.

We have begun to invest in this one single line, and the graphics were clearly drawn for execution. But they were drawn from the accounts, of course, that the airborne equipment will be delivered to us in time, and will not be denied. It was staged, but, unfortunately, followed by the already mentioned my failure devices, needed additional time to repair them, return, follow the installation and pereispytaniya. It knocked us out schedule for several projects, including through defense contracts.

montmein69 a écrit:...
Cela dit je ne sais pas ce qu'il en est dans ce cas précis, cela est peut-être l'occasion de "décaniller" des personnes pas trop dans les petits papiers de Poutine et d'en mettre d'autres à la place (sait on depuis combien de temps ces dirigeants occupaient leur "fauteuil" ?).

montmein69 a écrit:En occident on trouve souvent le travers inverse, an cas de gros pépins, les hauts responsables plaident "non coupables car je n'étais pas au courant" et épaulés par une armada d'avocats, au pire partent avec leur stock-options et une joli retraite-chapeau ... sinon sont recyclés avec avancement dans un autre conseil d'administration.

La "morale" n'a généralement aucune signification en matière de "business" dans un "système" comme dans l'autre.

patchfree a écrit:...
Perminov a été remercié de Roscosmos en raison de la limite d'âge mais il a retrouvé une position immédiate dans une société spatiale de premier plan...

peronik a écrit:
je ne connais pas le dossier mais je ne connais pas non plus l'avis de monsieur Mikhaïl Khodorkovski sur les "douceurs" des opérations "poutinniennes " Question pale Crying or Very sad mais j'avoue avoir quelques idées dessus

patchfree a écrit:Au fond ce que je critique c'est cette manière volontariste de tenter de modifier le cours des choses: quand il y a des difficultés il faut mieux les traiter à la source plutôt que de démettre des dirigeants.

patchfree a écrit:On sait de quoi souffre le spatial en Russie et cela ne date pas d'hier mais de l'ère soviétique: retard géant dans l'électronique dû à l'inefficacité du système de marché d'état de l'époque soviétique, peu de considération pour les métiers du savoir qui étaient (et restent) peu payés, phénomène aggravé actuellement par la vogue des métiers du commerce et de la finance en Russie (et partout dans le monde).

patchfree a écrit:Malgré ces "tares" l'intelligence et la compétence des ingénieurs russes demeurent et sont reconnus et peuvent s'appuyer sur l'héritage du spatial soviétique et une bonne expérience de faire du commerce à l'international sur des niches de basse ou de haute technologie.

Au lieu de "réprimander" les dirigeants ils feraient donc mieux d'améliorer les salaires des ingénieurs et de développer la formation. Ils semblent faire des efforts sur ce dernier point mais pour les salaires c'est pas gagné car la compétitivité les oblige à serrer les coûts...

New cleaning Roskosmos expect after the loss of "Express"


Opened after the telecommunications satellite "Express-AM4", displayed on an unplanned orbit August 18 and lost in space, is likely to lead to new major reshuffle in the Russian space agency, informs "Interfax" referring to a source in the industry.
"In With the recent change of leader in the industry Roscosmos expect major personnel changes. Obviously, the failure of the "Express-AM4" accelerate the implementation of these plans, "- said. In particular, he said, could lose their positions several deputy heads of the Russian Federal Space Agency, a number of heads of departments and agencies of Directors of the rocket and space companies.
The source did not rule out "draw conclusions" in respect of the leaders of the Khrunichev Space Center, which is generally responsible for preparation of running " Express-AM4 "and removing spacecraft into orbit. "According to reports, the carrier rocket" Proton-M ", which is produced by the Centre Khrunichev, to work normally. But there are questions for the upper stage" Briz-M ", which is also manufactured by this company," - said the source.
He confirmed that the damage the loss of the device is very large. "The spacecraft is made ​​by the European company of the means of the Russian budget. The cost of similar devices in the West, as a rule, 300-400 million euros. Accordingly, the loss could exceed 10 billion rubles," - said the source.
Earlier media reports referring to the experts, that damage, including launch costs, estimated at 20 billion rubles. According to "Ingosstrakh" satellite "Express-AM4" was insured for more than $ 7 billion rubles and reinsured in the international market.
In the opinion of an unnamed source agency, probably in the next few months will be removed from office and the heads of companies have admitted the failure of important state and defense contracts in the field of rocket and space technology: in particular, can be expected retirements VNIIEM heads, which draws on a number of spacecraft, including the Belarusian satellite.